City Cast Portland logo

Beheadings, Paganism, and Animal Blood: The Dark Origins of Valentine’s Day

Posted on February 12, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Natalia Aldana

Natalia Aldana

St. Valentine depicted in a dark robe with halo, 3 people lounging at his feet

An engraving of the martyred St. Valentine by an Italian artist in 1886. (Fototeca Storica Nazionale / Getty Images)

Valentine’s Day is a holiday filled with romance, love, and of course the commercialization of our appreciation for the special people in our lives. But the origins of this romantic holiday actually range from pretty dark to downright strange, depending on which folklore you believe.

Beheaded in the Name of Love

The Catholic Church recognizes several versions of a martyred St. Valentine. One story is that a priest by the name of Valentine, or Valentinus, married couples in secret after Roman Emperor Claudius II outlawed marriage for young men, thinking it would make them better soldiers. Another story is that an imprisoned Bishop Valentine of Tern sent a love note to his beloved and signed it, “From your Valentine.” All stories of the patron saints of lovers end with them being beheaded.

How Animal Blood Led to Marriage

Why do we celebrate on Feb. 14? Many credit the ancient pagan Roman festival of Lupercalia, which took place in mid-February. During this celebration of fertility, priests “gently” slapped women with goat hides dipped in blood, believing it would make them more fertile (which just sounds messy, right?). The party would end with young men drawing women’s names from jars, and they would be coupled up for the festival, which ideally would lead to their marriage.

From its Dark Origins to Modern-Day Interpretations

As the Romans departed from paganism, it’s believed the Catholic Church replaced this sexy celebration with St. Valentine’s Day. Another folklore is that the Norman people’s celebration of Galatin’s Day, the “lover of women,” (Galentine’s Day, anyone?!) was eventually combined with Valentine’s Day because of how similar they were pronounced. William Shakespeare and other writers are credited with romanticizing the holiday and creating mass appeal. At the turn of the 20th century, Hallmark Cards in Kansas City, Missouri began mass-producing Valentine’s Day cards.

Now that you know the dark origins of Valentine’s Day, does this day still inspire romance for you? Love is patient, love is kind, but never forget it can also be weird and dramatic. Happy Valentine’s Day!

Check out our list of Portland’s most romantic bars and restaurants — as well as our events listings ⬇️

City Cast

Portland’s Most Romantic Restaurants

00:00:00

Share article

Hey Portland

Stay connected to City Cast Portland and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Portland, Explained

See All
Portland, ExplainedMarch 12

How Well Do You Know Portland?

You can tell whether you’re a real Portland resident by how you pronounce local names. Or can you? Today’s quiz tests your Portland stree...

couch street sign
Portland, ExplainedMarch 10

The Portland Area’s Local Income Taxes, Explained

Here’s a reminder on all our local taxes due today: The Portland Arts Tax, Metro Supportive Housing Services, and Multnomah County Presch...

Cropped shot of Asian woman sitting at dining table, handling personal finance with laptop.
Portland, ExplainedFebruary 4

How Weird Is Portland's Warm Sunny Weather?

The dry, warm winter continues. Outdoor guide and lifelong Oregonian Norther Emily talked to City Cast Portland podcast host Claudia Meza...

daffodils, Portland, Oregon
Portland, ExplainedDecember 17, 2025

Portland's Water Comes From a Rain Forest

Clean and plentiful tap water is one of those creature comforts we usually never think about. But where does Portland’s water come from?...

a reservoir amid scenic forest and mountains in background
Portland, ExplainedDecember 16, 2025

Oregon Hunger, Explained

This fall, during the government shutdown, the Trump administration took the unprecedented step of temporarily cutting off federal food b...

vast container of green apples being bagged up
Portland, ExplainedDecember 9, 2025

Portland's Atmospheric River May Cause Flooding

Portland is getting a ton of rain right now. We’re in the midst of a weather phenomenon called an atmospheric river.

clouds over the Willamette River, Portland, Oregon, with highway traffic on right
Portland, ExplainedDecember 3, 2025

When Will the Snow Start on Mt. Hood?

Ski resorts like Timberline and Mt. Hood Meadows have yet to announce their opening days, so snowboarders and skiers are eyeing the forec...

snowy slope and a blue sky with mountain ranges in the background. Mt Hood, Oregon
Portland, ExplainedDecember 2, 2025

Why the Portland Airport Is Called PDX

Even an alien invader might notice that Portland regularly favors the nickname PDX — our airport abbreviation. That’s clear enough. But w...

Natural light shines on the unique print of the PDX portland airport carpet. Shadows from the support beams are present.

The latest in Portland

The Weekly Wander by City Cast PortlandMay 17

Side Quest: Porch Power

There’s something magical about gathering on the front steps and jamming with friends. If you’re looking for a way to meet new people or...

People sit in camp chairs underneath pop-up canopies in a driveway while listening to musicians play guitar in the front yard.
The Weekly Wander by City Cast PortlandMay 17

Your Guide to St. Johns

Despite being located on the city's periphery, St. Johns is a neighborhood built on connection; to the past — its iconic green-arched bri...

Cars and trucks cross the St. Johns Bridge on a sunny day. Traffic is flowing toward the viewer, and in the distance you can see Forest Park.
The Weekly Wander by City Cast PortlandMay 10

Side Quest: Inner Peace

The Vedanta Society of Portland, founded 100 years ago, is based in Mt. Tabor, but the group also oversees the Vedanta Retreat — 289 acre...

A large wooden eagle structure made in a Native American style is nestled among soaring evergreen trees at the Vedanta Retreat outside of Scappoose, Oregon.
The Weekly Wander by City Cast PortlandMay 10

Your Guide to Mt. Tabor

For a neighborhood built on and around an extinct volcano, Mt. Tabor is remarkably peaceful. You won’t catch a whiff of fire and brimston...

Looking west from Mt. Tabor, grass and yellow flowers sit in the foreground with evergreen trees and a filled reservoir beyond. Portland’s distant skyline can be seen on the horizon under an overcast sky.
Portland's BestApril 30

Your Guide to May 2026 in Portland

From Mother's Day brunches to 503 Day celebrations to the Primary Election, there's going on in Portland this month.

People on a podium having shot off confetti.
Food & DrinkApril 7

Where To Find the Best Deals for Portland Groceries

For the last year, Stumptown Savings’ Bryan M. Vance has been tracking where to find the cheap groceries in Portland. His one-person medi...

A grocery store aisle.
Portland's BestApril 1

Your Guide to April 2026 in Portland

Out on the Oregon Coast, April means it’s time to celebrate the puffin’s seasonal return to Cannon Beach, which will host an annual Puffi...

A closeup of a tufted puffin.
Portland's BestMarch 16

Where to Find Downtown Portland's Best Hotel Bars

With the opening of Damian Lillard's shiny new bar at the Benson Hotel, I've been thinking a lot about our city's hotel bar scene. For me...

people sitting curved banquettes and tables, at Abigail Hall, Portland, Oregon